MLB.com Allows Fans to Vote on Cubs' Best

As noted by the Chicago Cubs Online blog, MLB.com is running a "Hometown Heroes" vote for each major league team. The vote allows fans to vote for one all-time player from each team. Each team has five nominees. The Cubs' nominees are: Ernie Banks, Ferguson Jenkins, Ryne Sandberg, Ron Santo, and Billy Williams.

But what are we voting on? The MLB press release indicates that it is something other than just best player:

This multi-faceted program was created to recognize those players who most embody the legacy of Major League Baseball and each respective franchise's history. Beginning July 18, fans will have the opportunity to vote for the most outstanding player in the history of each MLB franchise based on specific criteria that makes the winner deserving of being called a hero.

The release goes on to note that nominees were selected based on "on-field performance, leadership quality and character value." That's why we don't see Sammy Sosa, who rivals Banks for best on-field performance, on the ballot. It's also likely why we see Jenkins instead of Mordecai Brown. While Jenkins was great, Brown was better, but Brown has escaped our collective memory while Jenkins still holds a place there.

I would be shocked if Banks did not win this vote.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Hometwon Heroes

I would think that Banks would have to win this also. Not too many teams have a guy who is both a) potentially their best player, and b) the face of the team's history, in the way that Banks is.

Babe Ruth, Cal Ripken, Roberto Clemente, George Brett, Ted Williams, Mike Schmidt, Tony Gwynn, Kirby Puckett ... that may be it.

Jenkins

Which reminds me, why hasn't Jenkins's number been retired?

Jenkins' number

I don't know the actual reason, but there a couple of significant distinctions between Jenkins and the other Cubs' players who have had their numbers retired:

1. He played a significant amount of time for other teams (the Rangers and the Red Sox).

2. He was arrested and convicted for drug possession (though the Canadian judge erased the conviction).

I don't really have a position on whether his number should be retired.

Sosa vs. Santo and Sandberg...

From the Chicago Tribune...

Chemistry all wrong for Sosa to make list
Published July 19, 2006

Sample:

I will give you Banks, Williams and Jenkins on that list. But it's almost impossible to find any statistical measure that says Santo and Sandberg were better than His Samminess.

Batting average: Sosa, .274; Sandberg, .285; Santo, .277.

Home runs: Sosa, 588; Sandberg, 282; Santo, 342.

Runs batted in: Sosa, 1,575; Sandberg, 1,061; Santo, 1,331.

Slugging percentage: Sosa, .537; Sandberg, .452; Santo, 464.

Seasons spent saving baseball: Sosa, 1; Sandberg, 0; Santo, 0.

http://www.chicagotribune.com/sports/bas...

Photos from Ryne Sandberg Day at Wrigley Field

Sammy Sosa photos

Meet Ronnie the Collie